Home
About
Articles
Links
Contact Dr. Hong





Please contact us here
Dr. John Hong
We look forward to hearing your questions and comments.

Alone Alone All All Alone: Tough times for some elderly

“We Are Family, I got all my sisters with me. Get up everybody and sing!”

Go, Sister Sledge! (But where are they now?)

Family is something so powerful, so encompassing, so– ah, complicated. The Partridge Family never had major conflict even though the show started with the death of Mr. Partridge. Wait a minute, even on The Brady Bunch, both Carol and Mike appeared to be widowed. Oh, God! The Courtship of Eddie’s Father was based on the death of Eddie’s mother. Oh, no! The Andy Griffith Show, My Three Sons, Eight is Enough, Family Affair– all were based on losing a parent and spouse. Jody! Buffy! Cissy!

You know, I never realized all of these favorite shows of mine were based on a beloved family member passing away. They are all comedies, so I never really focused on the fact that the kids were missing a parent. Talk about a Parent Trap! But these shows demonstrate that family members stick together and move on. But do family members really stick together until the end?

I joke that I don’t get older, I just get gooder. But the reality is that if I ever get to be elderly, I don’t know who is going to take care of me should I fall ill with dementia or cancer. (I definitely don’t want Anna Nicole Smith’s mother or Britney Spears to take over my care.) I have my advanced directives, power of attorney, etc. already taken care of at my tender age of 40, but who know what lies ahead?

Some of my toughest cases with patient care deal with elderly folk who are estranged— or worse yet, don’t acknowledge they are estranged– from immediate family members.

Patient: “Doc, I leave my kids alone, and they respect my privacy as well.”

Doctor: “When was the last time you talked to them?”

P: “Childbirth.”

D: “Don’t you think you should let them know you’re in trouble with your health and can’t live alone anymore?”

P: “I can take care of myself. Now can you do my groceries for me and get my laundry done? I’m hungry and I smell bad.”

Sometimes these types of patients won’t even let me call their kids or other immediate family members, so I have to act like Rosanne Barr (i.e. nag, nag, nag) to convince them that I need to speak to family. Unfortunately, some people don’t have any immediate family.

In our lovely world of dysfunctional families, I sometimes regret being able to talk to the kids. I once had a demented and dangerous patient who needed to go to a nursing home, and the son did everything but buy his parent an AK-47 and anthrax. He could not accept his parent was ill and did everything possible to ignore medical advice.

I have had quite a few kids of patients act like Lindsay Lohan when I’ve been on the phone with them.

D: “I’m sorry to tell you that your mother is on a ventilation machine and is not doing well.”

Child: “Cool, so things are going well?”

D: “No, things aren’t going well. I think you should come here now because things are going poorly.”

C: “I’m so glad you’re doing everything you can to help Mum. You’re awesome.”

D: “Ah, do you understand what I am saying? Your mom may not be around much longer.”

C: “You can email me on the cruise ship when Mum’s better. Isn’t it great what modern technology allows us to do?”

Maybe I’ll open up a new business, “Rent a Child,” for those in need of a healthy thinking (i.e. sane) adult child who can step in when needed. All my employees will be well-versed in The Brady Bunch and The Andy Griffith Show.

© John S Hong, MD, MS April 18, 2007

12 Comments

  1. Awesome and you use humor to make your point! I hope this is being collected for a book.

    I am going to send this to our son who graduates med school on June 2.

    Comment by Lin Cote — April 20, 2007 @ 7:20 pm

  2. This is one of your best columns yet. The conversation between the doctor and the “child” at the end was a hoot. It reminds me of some of my own relatives!

    Comment by Neil — April 20, 2007 @ 8:50 pm

  3. As a Nursing Home Administrator I was confronted with many situations like the one you quote. The other one is guilt. Many children try to “dump” that guilt onto Nursinghomes by demanding the impossible and refusing to accept that their guilt is getting in the way of working in tandem with the Nursinghome in order to provide the best care for their family member. One other point. Very few men step up to the plate when it comes to the care of their parents. Men tend to pass that “chore” on to their female family members (wives, sisters, sisters inlaws, daughter inlaws etc).
    Even tho the minority of our elderly are in Nursinghomes, if I were powerful to make a change:
    I would give families of an elderly person needing care, the opportunity to accept a realistically set payment to take care of that elderly person at home. I bet a lot of caring families would take that route. :-)

    Comment by Brigitte Powell — April 21, 2007 @ 5:16 am

  4. WHAT!!!!
    No MADONNA?

    Comment by ELVIS — April 21, 2007 @ 11:42 am

  5. YOU ROCK!! I love the site! You are such a great doctor - that is why I send my friends and family to you!

    Let me know if you ever need a “guest writer”!

    See you soon!

    T

    Comment by Tracey Saxon — April 21, 2007 @ 2:35 pm

  6. I love it!(your web site)If you need help with “Rent A Child”,I got 3 of them.

    Comment by Ed — April 22, 2007 @ 7:08 am

  7. Love the site. I miss Charlottesville. Chicago is treating me well, but, it’s not home. Hope to be back some day. Can’t find a Dr. up here with a 1/4 of your talent and expertise. Take Care,
    Lisa McAbee

    Comment by Lisa McAbee — April 22, 2007 @ 1:31 pm

  8. dear john,
    I like your website very much. This article about elderly parents speaks for its self.
    Thank you. My children are pleased that you have cxorresponded with them.
    good Luck with your website.
    May

    Comment by may Kingman — April 22, 2007 @ 1:33 pm

  9. I really like the new looks of your page.One day I will get a computer, but now I am low-tech. See you soon…..

    Comment by MG Flood — April 22, 2007 @ 8:53 pm

  10. I love the website. You did a great job.

    Cheers!!

    Comment by Sheila White — April 23, 2007 @ 5:04 am

  11. Love it.

    Comment by Kathy Hall — April 23, 2007 @ 5:33 am

  12. Just visited your new web site, Dr. John…
    really liked and enjoyed it….40??? you don’t look a day over……..???
    Brian

    Comment by Brian Cote — April 24, 2007 @ 6:45 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.